Choosing replacement trays for an Excalibur dehydrator starts with one measurement: the tray size your model actually takes. For compatible 15-inch units, I rate the Bright Kitchen 9-Pack Stainless Steel Trays as the strongest full-set option because it replaces every tray in a five- or nine-tray machine with dishwasher-safe steel. The Excalibur P43 polyscreen inserts suit owners who want to keep their original trays and need mesh for small or sticky foods, while the Bright Kitchen 3-Pack offers a smaller stainless steel upgrade when replacing a full set is unnecessary. The key tradeoff is between durable steel trays that food can sit on directly and lighter mesh inserts that sit on existing trays. A 15-inch replacement tray is not interchangeable with an 11-inch insert for a four-tray Excalibur, so I’ve ranked these by fit, material, quantity, and the job each one actually does.
Get health and wellness essentials delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
For a complete stainless steel refresh: the Bright Kitchen 9-pack supplies nine 15 × 15-inch trays for compatible five- and nine-tray Excalibur models.
For small or sticky foods on original trays: Excalibur’s five-pack of 14 × 14-inch polyscreen inserts is the purpose-built mesh option for five- and nine-tray units, including model P43.
For partial steel replacement: the Bright Kitchen 3-pack lets owners replace several 15-inch trays without buying a nine-tray set, though a full nine-tray conversion takes multiple packs.
For four-tray machines: Bright Kitchen’s 11 × 11-inch inserts are the only listed option specified for four-tray Excalibur dehydrators.
Check tray dimensions before ordering: the steel options listed here need 15-inch square tray capacity, while the Excalibur mesh inserts are 14 inches and the four-tray inserts are 11 inches.
| replacement trays for excalibur model | Material | Compatibility | Quantity | Dimensions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bright Kitchen Stainless Steel | Food-grade 304 stainless steel | 5- and 9-tray Excalibur models; other dehydrators using 15-inch square trays | — | 15 × 15 inches |
| Excalibur 14" x 14" Polyscreen | Food-safe plastic | 5- and 9-tray Excalibur dehydrators | 5 inserts | 14 × 14 inches |
| Bright Kitchen 3-Pack Stainles | 100% 304 stainless steel | 5- and 9-tray Excalibur dehydrators | 3 trays | — |
| Bright Kitchen 11 x 11-Inch Po | BPA-free plastic | 4-tray Excalibur dehydrators | 4 inserts | — |
| Bright Kitchen Stainless Steel | Stainless steel | 5- and 9-tray Excalibur models; other dehydrators using 15-inch square trays | 1 tray | 15 × 15 inches |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Bright Kitchen Stainless Steel Dehydrator Trays for Excalibur, 9-Pack
For owners of a compatible five- or nine-tray Excalibur, this is the most straightforward way in this lineup to replace a set rather than patch one damaged tray at a time. Its nine 15 × 15-inch trays are made from food-grade 304 stainless steel, and food can sit directly on the mesh without a separate plastic screen. That makes this a different kind of purchase from the Excalibur P43 inserts: those add mesh on top of an existing tray, while this set replaces the tray surface itself.
The care details also favor the nine-pack for regular use. It is dishwasher-safe and can be steam-cleaned, and steel avoids the cracking and heat-related breakdown associated with plastic trays. Compared with Bright Kitchen’s three-pack, the nine-pack is better for a full refresh, especially when outfitting a nine-tray machine; the three-pack is easier to justify if only a few trays need replacing. The main limitation is fit: the dehydrator must use 15-inch square trays. Measure or confirm the model format before ordering, since the 14-inch Excalibur inserts and 11-inch four-tray inserts serve different purposes.
Pros:- Nine trays can cover a compatible full-size set.
- Food sits directly on food-grade 304 stainless steel mesh.
- Dishwasher-safe and steam-cleanable.
- No separate plastic mesh liner is required.
Cons:- Fit depends on having 15-inch square tray capacity.
- A full nine-piece set may be more than needed for a minor replacement.
Best for: Owners of a compatible five- or nine-tray Excalibur who want to replace most or all trays with washable stainless steel.
Not ideal for: Owners of four-tray machines, dehydrators with a different tray size, or anyone who only needs mesh inserts for existing trays.
- Material:Food-grade 304 stainless steel
- Dimensions:15 × 15 inches
- Pack size:9 trays
- Compatibility:5- and 9-tray Excalibur models; other dehydrators using 15-inch square trays
- Cleaning:Dishwasher-safe; steam-cleanable
- Separate liner:Not required
Our verdict“I’d choose this set for a compatible Excalibur owner who wants the clearest path to a full stainless steel tray upgrade.”
Excalibur 14″ x 14″ Polyscreen Mesh Tray Screen Inserts for 5 and 9 Tray Dehydrators (5 Pack)
This five-pack fits buyers who want to keep their existing Excalibur trays and add a finer surface for herbs, chopped ingredients, or sticky pieces that could fall through. The 14 × 14-inch food-safe plastic screens are specified for five- and nine-tray Excalibur dehydrators, including model P43. That clear model association gives this insert an advantage over the stainless steel replacements when an owner wants a screen insert rather than a different tray material.
Compared with the Bright Kitchen steel options, the P43 screens do not replace the tray or remove plastic from the drying surface. They are instead a reusable layer for targeted jobs, and the five-piece quantity can provide screens for several trays at once. That distinction matters: if the goal is to stop using a cracked plastic tray, the steel nine-pack or three-pack is more aligned with the task. Plastic mesh may also be less durable than silicone alternatives, and the supplied compatibility is limited to Excalibur machines. I would confirm the model and insert dimensions if buying for anything outside the listed fit.
Pros:- Specified for five- and nine-tray Excalibur dehydrators.
- Mesh helps keep small foods from falling through.
- Five inserts provide several screens or spares.
- Food-safe plastic screen material.
Cons:- These are inserts, not replacement trays.
- Plastic mesh may not last as well as silicone alternatives.
- Compatibility is limited to Excalibur dehydrators.
Best for: Excalibur five- or nine-tray owners who want brand-specific mesh inserts for small or sticky foods while retaining their original trays.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking stainless steel tray replacements, a four-tray insert, or a screen for a non-Excalibur dehydrator.
- Brand:Excalibur
- Model:P43
- Part number:EXCP43
- Quantity:5 inserts
- Dimensions:14 × 14 inches
- Material:Food-safe plastic
- Compatibility:5- and 9-tray Excalibur dehydrators
- Color:Black
Our verdict“I’d pick the P43 pack when the tray itself is serviceable and the missing piece is a model-specific screen for small foods.”
Bright Kitchen 3-Pack Stainless Steel Mesh Trays for Excalibur Dehydrators (15″ x 15″)
A three-pack makes more sense than the nine-pack when only a few trays need replacing or when an owner wants to try steel on the trays used most often. These 15 × 15-inch 304 stainless steel trays are described for five- and nine-tray Excalibur dehydrators. Food can go directly on the mesh, so there is no plastic screen to position or remove during cleanup. Dishwasher and steam-cleaning compatibility also support a more thorough wash than a screen insert laid over an old tray.
The tradeoff is quantity. Compared with the nine-pack, this set will not cover a full nine-tray machine; buying several packs for that purpose adds purchasing complexity. It is also less appropriate than the Excalibur P43 inserts for someone who only needs finer mesh for small foods and wants to preserve original trays. Its role is a selective steel replacement, with the same fit constraint as the other 15-inch options: the dehydrator must accept square trays of that size. The product description says it fits all five- and nine-tray Excalibur dehydrators, but checking the actual tray dimensions remains the safer way to match replacements.
Pros:- Three 304 stainless steel trays for targeted replacement.
- Food rests directly on the mesh without plastic liners.
- Dishwasher-safe and steam-cleanable.
- Resists cracking associated with plastic trays.
Cons:- A full nine-tray conversion may require multiple packs.
- Only fits dehydrators that accept 15-inch square trays.
Best for: Owners of compatible five- or nine-tray Excalibur units replacing a few trays or upgrading in stages to stainless steel.
Not ideal for: Buyers needing a complete nine-tray set immediately, or those who only want mesh screens for existing trays.
- Material:100% 304 stainless steel
- Tray size:15 × 15 inches
- Quantity:3 trays
- Compatibility:5- and 9-tray Excalibur dehydrators
- Care:Dishwasher-safe; steam-cleanable
- Color:Silver
- Shape:Square
Our verdict“I’d choose this pack for a gradual or partial steel upgrade, while the nine-pack is the simpler choice for a complete replacement.”
Bright Kitchen 11 x 11-Inch PolyScreen Mesh Inserts for 4-Tray Excalibur Dehydrators, 4 Pack
This is the lineup’s fit-specific choice for an Excalibur four-tray dehydrator. Each 11 × 11-inch BPA-free plastic screen is a reusable insert for drying small foods such as herbs, fruit, and vegetables. The four-piece pack matches the tray count implied by its intended machine, while hand-washing or dishwasher care lets owners reuse the screens across batches.
Its role is narrower than the 14-inch Excalibur P43 pack: those inserts are specified for five- and nine-tray models, whereas these are made for four-tray Excalibur dehydrators. Neither insert set replaces the underlying tray. If a tray has cracked or the goal is to move food off plastic surfaces, Bright Kitchen’s stainless steel options offer a different solution, but their 15-inch dimensions do not match the listed 11-inch insert format. The key drawback is strict model fit, so this is a poor choice for a larger Excalibur even if the brand name matches. Trays are not included.
Pros:- Sized specifically for four-tray Excalibur dehydrators.
- Reusable screen surface suits small foods.
- BPA-free plastic construction.
- Dishwasher-safe or hand-washable.
Cons:- Does not fit five- or nine-tray Excalibur models.
- Plastic trays are not included.
- Plastic mesh is not a stainless steel replacement.
Best for: Owners of a four-tray Excalibur dehydrator who need washable screens for small or delicate foods.
Not ideal for: Owners of five- or nine-tray Excalibur models, or buyers who need full replacement trays rather than inserts.
- Quantity:4 inserts
- Size:11 × 11 inches
- Material:BPA-free plastic
- Compatibility:4-tray Excalibur dehydrators
- Care:Dishwasher-safe or hand-wash
- Color:Black
- Trays included:No
Our verdict“I’d select these only for a four-tray Excalibur that needs 11-inch screens for small foods.”
Bright Kitchen Stainless Steel Replacement Tray for Excalibur Dehydrators
When one tray is damaged or missing, this individual 15-inch square stainless steel tray avoids buying a multi-piece pack. Food sits directly on the steel, so there is no separate mesh sheet to keep track of, and the product is described as easy to wash. Its stated fit covers five- and nine-tray Excalibur dehydrators as well as other machines that use 15-inch square trays.
Compared with the Bright Kitchen three-pack, the single tray is more targeted for an isolated replacement; compared with the nine-pack, it is a poor match for a full set refresh. The supplied details do not specify a stainless steel grade or care method as clearly as the 304-steel multi-packs, so buyers prioritizing those stated material and cleaning details may prefer the nine- or three-pack. Its broad fit claim still depends on dimensions: it is not a universal Excalibur tray, and it will not suit four-tray units using the listed 11-inch format. Confirm your existing tray size before choosing this one.
Pros:- Single tray suits an isolated replacement need.
- Stainless steel surface needs no separate mesh sheet.
- Specified for five- and nine-tray Excalibur models.
- Also fits other dehydrators using 15-inch square trays.
Cons:- Only one tray is included.
- Compatibility depends on 15-inch square tray capacity.
- The supplied details do not identify a steel grade or specific cleaning method.
Best for: A compatible five- or nine-tray Excalibur owner who needs one 15-inch square tray rather than a set.
Not ideal for: Buyers replacing several trays, seeking explicit 304 stainless steel specifications, or shopping for an 11-inch four-tray model.
- Material:Stainless steel
- Dimensions:15 × 15 inches
- Quantity:1 tray
- Compatibility:5- and 9-tray Excalibur models; other dehydrators using 15-inch square trays
- Separate mesh sheet:Not required
- Shape:Square
Our verdict“I’d use this as a one-for-one replacement when a single tray is missing and its 15-inch dimensions match.”
How We Picked
I ranked these options around the needs implied by replacement trays for Excalibur models: getting the right fit, choosing between replacing a tray and lining one, and buying a quantity that matches the repair or upgrade. A stated Excalibur fit matters, but I also looked at the listed dimensions because Excalibur machines differ by tray format. Compatibility claims do not make differently sized products interchangeable.
Material and care shape the next part of the ranking. The stainless steel trays let food rest directly on the mesh and are described as dishwasher-safe; that makes them a more complete tray replacement than a plastic insert. The polyscreen options instead add a finer surface to existing trays, which can help contain small pieces but leave the original tray in place. I considered quantity too: a nine-pack can outfit a compatible nine-tray unit in one purchase, while three- and five-piece packs are better suited to partial replacement or insert replenishment.
Finally, I gave each product a distinct role rather than treating every option as a general-purpose winner. The nine-pack ranks first for broad replacement coverage, followed by the Excalibur inserts for users who need the brand-specific screen format. The three-pack steel set is a practical partial upgrade; the four-tray inserts serve a narrower machine size; and the single stainless tray is the most limited quantity option. I based these comparisons on the supplied product details and do not infer fit for models or dimensions that are not specified.
| replacement trays for excalibur model | Color |
|---|---|
| Bright Kitchen Stainless Steel | — |
| Excalibur 14" x 14" Polyscreen | Black |
| Bright Kitchen 3-Pack Stainles | Silver |
| Bright Kitchen 11 x 11-Inch Po | Black |
| Bright Kitchen Stainless Steel | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Replacement Trays For Excalibur Models
I would decide first whether the damaged part is the tray itself or only the mesh surface used on top of it. That choice separates the stainless steel replacements from the plastic insert packs, and prevents buying a screen that cannot replace a cracked tray.
Match dimensions and tray count
Start by checking your dehydrator model and measuring an existing tray. The stainless steel products here are 15 × 15 inches and are listed for five- and nine-tray Excalibur machines. The P43 inserts measure 14 × 14 inches and are specified for five- and nine-tray models, while Bright Kitchen’s four-tray inserts measure 11 × 11 inches. These dimensions refer to different product formats and do not imply that one size can substitute for another. If you are unsure, compare the new part with the original tray or confirm the model’s requirements before ordering.
Choose a tray replacement or a screen insert
A stainless steel replacement takes the place of a tray; the plastic polyscreen options are inserts intended to sit on the existing tray. Steel suits a buyer who wants food directly on a washable metal mesh surface and wants to avoid a separate liner. An insert is more focused: it adds a screen to catch small foods while leaving the tray in service. I would pick an insert for herbs, small pieces, or sticky foods when the underlying tray is still usable. If the tray is cracked, an insert does not address that structural problem.
Decide how much to replace at once
Pack size changes which option is practical. The nine-pack can cover a compatible nine-tray machine in one purchase, while the three-pack is better for replacing selected trays or upgrading gradually. The single Bright Kitchen tray is the most targeted choice for one damaged part. For screens, the five-pack P43 set can serve multiple trays in a five- or nine-tray unit, while the four-pack of 11-inch inserts is aimed at the four-tray model. Match the quantity to how many surfaces you actually need to replace or cover.
Weigh cleaning and material preferences
The steel options are described as easy to wash, and the nine- and three-packs specifically state dishwasher-safe care; both can also be steam-cleaned. The plastic inserts are reusable and washable, and the Bright Kitchen four-tray screens are listed as dishwasher-safe or hand-washable. If avoiding plastic on the food-contact surface is a priority, the steel trays have the clearest fit with that preference. If you prefer to retain the original trays and only need a fine screen, inserts keep the change limited to the foods that need one.
Check what is included
Product titles can make tray and screen products sound similar, so verify the pack contents before ordering. The stainless steel products are trays, with one, three, or nine included depending on the listing. The P43 and Bright Kitchen four-tray products are mesh inserts; the four-tray listing explicitly excludes trays. A screen insert cannot restore a missing tray, and a replacement tray may not provide the fine screen surface you want for tiny pieces. Confirm both the item type and quantity against your intended use.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know which replacement tray size fits my Excalibur?
Check your model’s tray format and measure an original tray if available. The steel replacements in this roundup are 15 × 15 inches for compatible five- and nine-tray models. The mesh inserts are separate formats: 14 × 14 inches for the listed five- and nine-tray Excalibur fit, or 11 × 11 inches for the four-tray model. Confirm that the product is intended for your model and whether it is a tray or an insert.
Are the polyscreen products replacement trays?
No. The Excalibur P43 and Bright Kitchen four-tray options are mesh inserts that go on existing trays. They can help contain small foods, but they do not replace the tray underneath. The Bright Kitchen stainless steel products are the actual replacement trays in this selection.
Which option is best for replacing all nine trays?
For a compatible Excalibur that uses 15-inch square trays, the Bright Kitchen nine-pack is the most direct full-set option listed here. It supplies nine stainless steel trays and does not require a separate mesh liner. Check your model’s tray dimensions first, since the four-tray Excalibur screens and the 14-inch inserts are different products with different purposes.
Can I use the stainless steel trays without mesh liners?
Yes. The Bright Kitchen steel trays are described as allowing food to sit directly on their mesh surface without a separate plastic mesh sheet. That is a key difference from the polyscreen products, which are themselves inserts used with existing trays. The steel models still need to match your dehydrator’s tray dimensions.
Which product suits a four-tray Excalibur?
The Bright Kitchen 11 × 11-inch PolyScreen inserts are the product in this roundup specified for four-tray Excalibur dehydrators. They are screens for small foods, not replacement trays, and the listing says trays are not included. The 15-inch steel trays and 14-inch P43 inserts have different stated compatibility, so do not assume they fit a four-tray machine.
Conclusion
For a full stainless steel refresh on a compatible five- or nine-tray Excalibur, I’d start with the Bright Kitchen nine-pack. If you only need a few steel trays, the three-pack fits a gradual upgrade, while the single stainless steel tray is the most focused choice for replacing one missing or damaged piece. Owners keeping their original trays and drying small or sticky foods should look at the Excalibur P43 inserts for five- and nine-tray machines; four-tray owners should choose the 11-inch Bright Kitchen inserts instead. In every case, match the product type and dimensions to your dehydrator before ordering.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
